BENNINGTON TRIANGLE
Photo by RootsRated
BENNINGTON, VT
HISTORY
There are those locations on this planet where people seem destined to disappear without a trace and
with no explanation. The Bermuda Triangle and the Dragon's Triangle are two such notorious locations where
the puzzling and bizarre disappearances of planes, ships and the people who pilot them have long been a
source of wonder and frustration for those who have sought to make sense of the events that have unfolded
there throughout the years.
But there is another lesser known but equally baffling source of mysterious happenings hitting even
closer to home because it happens to be in the continental U.S. in the most unlikeliest of places - the
beautiful and picturesque southwest mountains of Vermont. To be precise, the Glastenbury Mountain range
(below).
There has always been a sense of foreboding surrounding the mountain as Native American legend has
it the mountain as it is a place where the four winds meet. While local Indians stayed clear of it, they also
used it as a burial ground.
The first European settlers to the area reported witnessing strange lights in the sky, peculiar noises
emanating from the woods and foul odors that could not be readily identified. Tales were told of bizarre
creatures residing in the swamps and a Bigfoot-like entity that came to be known as the "Bennington
Monster" that reportedly flipped over a stagecoach on what is now Route 9 in that town.
Originally, the town was called Glastenbury and was a thriving logging town, but by 1937 was
unincorporated by the state of Vermont after a series of misfortune including wide-spread disease and the
harsh New England elements claimed a heavy toll on the residents. The much-celebrated story of Henry
MacDowell, who murdered fellow millworker Jim Crowley in 1892 also did little to place Glastenbury in a
favorable light in a state still in its infancy. MacDowell was subsequently sentenced to spend his life
institutionalized, but escaped and vanished without a trace - never to be found.
This incident was merely a portend of the extraordinary and tragic happenings that would plague the
area for years to come.
THE UNEXPLAINED VANISHINGS WITHIN THE BENNINGTON TRIANGLE
On November 12, 1945, a long-time hunting and fishing guide named Middie Rivers was leading a group
of hunters into the woods as he had many times before. Middie was a man of seventy-four who was
experienced and comfortable in the wild. While returning to camp at day's end, he went off ahead of the
hunters and seemingly vanished off the face of the earth. Police search parties found what only added to the
mystery: a bullet found next to a stream. It was surmised while taking a drink from the crystal waters the
bullet fell out of his pocket, but Maddie Rivers was never heard from again.
December 1, 1946 - just over one year later - an eighteen-year-old sophomore at Bennington College
named Paula Welden (below) hitched a ride and set out on a hike on the Long Trail. Her trip was not spur-of-
the-moment as she had told many of her intention to do so. One of those who knew of her excursion into the
forest was local newspaper employee Ernest Whitman, whom she had asked for directions. An old couple
that were walking behind Paula by no more than 100 yards claimed to have seen her turn a corner, but upon
reaching the same turn saw no trace of her. A massive man-hunt ensued with FBI and local authorities aided
by local townspeople and many of the student body of Bennington College all joining in the search. Police
went to far as to contact a clairvoyant for assistance and offer a $5,000 reward for any information regarding
her disappearance. All was to no avail as no sign or remains of Paula Welden were ever found. She was
declared legally dead in 1956. Because of the inability of local police to deal with such an incident, the
Vermont State Police was established.
(An aside to this story is that authorities arrested a man who had slashed another with a knife and robbed
him. The assailant had newspaper clippings about the Welden case on him at the time of his arrest, but no
link could be established and charges were never filed against him.)
Disturbingly, two years to the day - December 1, 1949 - a 68-year-old resident of
the Bennington Soldier's Home named Jamed Tetford (r.) was in St. Albans visiting
relatives. When the visit was over, Tetford boarded a bus and headed for home.
Witnesses say they saw him board the bus and was on it when they made a short
stop before their destination. When they finally arrived in Bennington, instead of the
confirmed 15 passengers, there were only 14 that got off. Tetford was seen sleeping
on the bus, but someway, somehow had vanished en route leaving his belongings in
the luggage rack and a bus timetable on the seat. Like the others, despite an
intensive search for the elderly veteran, he never turned up again.
A most heart-rendering occurrence took place on Columbus Day in 1950 when 8-
year-old Paul Jepson disappeared. The youngster was playing in the yard of the family home while his
mother was feeding livestock. When she came out to call him in, she could not find him. Paul was wearing a
bright red coat at the moment of his disappearance. Literally hundreds of volunteers combed the area
searching for the boy, but came up empty. In a strange twist, Paul father stated his son expressed a peculiar
desire days earlier to venture into the mountains. While not ever verified, there is an accompanying story that
states bloodhounds tracked him to the exact spot where Paula Welden had last been seen four years earlier.
A more believable, but equally disturbing twist is that the dogs tracked him to a spot near the highway where
they lost the scent - as if Paul had simply vanished from that spot.
Just two and-a-half weeks later on October 28th, 53-year-old Frieda Langer (l.) left
the family campground near the Somerset Reservoir for a hike with her cousin Herbert
Elsner. Before they had gotten very far, she slipped and fell into a stream, soaking her
clothes. Telling her cousin she was going back to change and would catch up with him,
she started back for camp. . .and never got there. When Herbert returned ands asked
about her he was told no one had seen her since they had left originally. Again a
massive search was conducted including planes and helicopters, but no sign of Frieda
was found. Until 6 months later.
On May 12, 1951, the badly decomposed body of Frieda was discovered in the
reservoir area. The location of her body was one that had been thoroughly searched at
the time of her disappearance and there was no chance her body would have been
overlooked. Because of the advanced state of decay, no cause of death could be determined. One
unsubstantiated report was that her face resembled someone who had been "frightened to death". Frieda
Langer remains to this day the only missing person ever to turn up in the Bennington Triangle.
Rumors abound that many more people vanished during the years
between 1945 and 1950, but not all activity seemed to end after Frieda Langer
was found. On August 27, 2011, Marble Arvidson, 17,(r.) was left his apartment
in Brattleboro at or around 2 P.M. with an unidentified male companion.
Marble’s family informed investigators that he was an avid hiker, and took his
boots with him when he left. There is some speculation that he could have
been a victim of Hurricane Irene, which hit the area the very same day he
vanished. Despite an extensive search, no trace of the young man has ever
been found.
The exact cause of these disappearances has been hotly debated through the
years and many theories have been put forth from the Bennington Monster to an enchanted Indian stone that
"swallows" anyone who steps on it to a portal to another dimension that these poor souls accidental stepped
into and vanished forever.
Alien abduction always winds up on anyone's short list of probable cause and there has also been the
not-so-far fetched idea that a serial killer was loose in the mountains and claimed these people as victims,
although because of the varying ages and genders of the victims developing a definitive profile is difficult at
best. There are also rumors that in Paula Welden's case, she was having problems at home and ran off to
Canada with a boyfriend or still lives as a recluse up in the mountains.
Despite the absence of hard evidence as well as the presence of intense speculation, no firm reason for
this spate of vanishings has ever been put forth and all cases remain unsolved.